[sigcomm] CCR shadow reviewing for students and junior faculties

[Armando L. Caro, Jr.]

Christophe Diot wrote:
<snip>
> 
> The rule to participate would be similar to the one used last year for the 
> shadow PC: be a PhD student or be a recent faculty who has never been involved 
> in a conference TPC.
<snip>
> This email has 2 purposes:
> 
> - get comments (positive or negative) on this idea; and

I like the idea, but why is it limited to PhD students and recent
faculty? I think it should also include recent PhD graduates that are
not in academia and who have never been involved in a conference TPC.

-- 
Armando
www.armandocaro.net