[sigcomm] CCR shadow reviewing for students and junior faculties

[Christophe Diot]

At the last CCR editor's meeting, we decided to put together a parallel 
reviewing process where (in short) PhD students and junior faculties could 
choose papers to review among CCR submissions.

The rule to participate would be similar to the one used last year for the 
shadow PC: be a PhD student or be a recent faculty who has never been involved 
in a conference TPC.

The idea is that these "shadow" reviews would be checked by the editor in charge 
of the paper and if they are good, be forwarded to the paper authors' with the 
official reviews. The authors of the shadow review would receive the official 
reviews together with the decision of the CCR editor.

We need a simple web page where reviewer candidates could register by research 
interest, view submitted papers and select the one they want to review. the rest 
of the process can be handled by email.

This email has 2 purposes:

- get comments (positive or negative) on this idea; and
- find a volunteer to develop the web page.

merci / christophe
-- 
Christophe Diot
Thomson Paris Research Lab
46, quai A. Le Gallo
92648 Boulogne cedex

+33-674-51-96-53