[sigcomm] CCR editorial notes -- please post !

[Lars Eggert]

Hi,

On 2007-9-20, at 9:31, ext Christophe Diot wrote:
> These articles are called "editorial notes" and can be workshop
> summaries, interviews, position papers, technical argument, personal
> view, etc. They are not reviewed ; but they are sanity checked to  
> avoid
> personal rant and/or commercial ads.

unless you've recently changed policy, past personal experience  
indicates that there is more to the "sanity check" than you suggest.  
I'd encourage you to be more specific about what kind of review  
editorial notes undergo.

(Background: We had originally submitted [1] as a position paper for  
the editorial section of CCR and got what one might call a "technical  
review light". That doesn't seem to go along with the policy you  
outline above.)

Lars

[1] Towards More Expressive Transport-Layer Interfaces. Lars Eggert  
and Wesley Eddy. Proc. IEEE/ACM Workshop on Mobility in the Evolving  
Internet Architecture (MobiArch), San Francisco, CA, USA, December 1,  
2006, pp. 71-74. http://people.nokia.net/~lars/papers/2006-mobiarch- 
transport-interfaces.pdf
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: smime.p7s
Type: application/pkcs7-signature
Size: 2446 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman.postel.org/pipermail/sigcomm/attachments/20070920/59163adb/smime.bin